Short-Term and Working Memory Treatments for Improving Sentence Comprehension in Aphasia: A Review and a Replication Study

Abstract

Although the roles of verbal short-term and working memory on spoken sentence comprehension skills in persons with aphasia have been debated for many years, the development of treatments to mitigate verbal short-term and working memory deficits as a way of improving spoken sentence comprehension is a new avenue in treatment research. In this article, we review and critically appraise this emerging evidence base. We also present new data from five persons with aphasia of a replication of a previously reported treatment that had resulted in some improvement of spoken sentence comprehension in a person with aphasia. The replicated treatment did not result in improvements in sentence comprehension. We forward recommendations for future research in this, admittedly weak at present, but important clinical research avenue that would help improve our understanding of the mechanisms of improvement of short-term and working memory training in relation to sentence comprehension.

Keywords

Aphasia - sentence comprehension - treatment - short-term memory - working memory

• References

• 1 Howard D, Nickels L. Separating input and output phonology: semantic, phonological, and orthographic effects in short-term memory impairment. Cogn Neuropsychol 2005; 22 (01) 42-77
• 2 Murray LL. Attention and other cognitive deficits in aphasia: presence and relation to language and communication measures. Am J Speech Lang Pathol 2012; 21 (02) S51-S64
• 3 Wright HH, Fergadiotis G. Conceptualising and measuring working memory and its relationship to aphasia. Aphasiology 2012; 26 (3-4): 258-278
• 4 Caplan D, Michaud J, Hufford R. Short-term memory, working memory, and syntactic comprehension in aphasia. Cogn Neuropsychol 2013; 30 (02) 77-109
• 5 Martin RC, Allen CM. A disorder of executive function and its role in language processing. Semin Speech Lang 2008; 29 (03) 201-210 , C, 4–5
• 6 Martin N, Ayala J. Measurements of auditory-verbal STM span in aphasia: effects of item, task, and lexical impairment. Brain Lang 2004; 89 (03) 464-483
• 7 Baddeley A. Working memory: theories, models, and controversies. Annu Rev Psychol 2012; 63: 1-29
• 8 Vallar G, Papagno C. Neuropsychological impairments of verbal short-term memory. In: Baddeley AD, Kopelman MD, Wilson BA. , eds. The Handbook of Memory Disorders. 2nd ed. Chichester, UK: Wiley; 2002: 249-270
• 9 Salis C. Short-term memory treatment: patterns of learning and generalisation to sentence comprehension in a person with aphasia. Neuropsychol Rehabil 2012; 22 (03) 428-448
• 10 Francis DR, Clark N, Humphreys GW. The treatment of an auditory working memory deficit and the implications for sentence comprehension abilities in mild “receptive” aphasia. Aphasiology 2003; 17: 723-750
• 11 McNeil MR, Prescott TE. The Revised Token Test. Baltimore, MD: University Park Press; 1978
• 12 Byng S, Black M. Reversible Sentence Comprehension Test. Oxford, UK: Winslow; 1999
• 13 Bishop DVM. Test for Reception of Grammar. 2nd ed. Manchester, UK: DVM Bishop & the Age and Cognitive Performance Research Centre; 1989
• 14 Harris L, Olson A, Humphreys G. The link between STM and sentence comprehension: a neuropsychological rehabilitation study. Neuropsychol Rehabil 2014; 24 (05) 678-720
• 15 Kay J, Lesser R, Coltheart M. Psycholinguistic Assessments of Language Processing in Aphasia. Hove, UK: Psychology Press; 1992
• 16 Zakariás L, Keresztes A, Marton K, Wartenburger I. Positive effects of a computerised working memory and executive function training on sentence comprehension in aphasia. Neuropsychol Rehabil 2016; 1-18
• 17 Mayer JF, Murray LL. Measuring working memory deficits in aphasia. J Commun Disord 2012; 45 (05) 325-339
• 18 Lukács Á, Győri M, Rózsa S. A TROG pszichometriai jellemzőinek magyar vizsgálata, a normák kialakítása [The psychometric analysis of Hungarian data from the TROG]. In: Bishop DVM. , ed. TROG—Test for Reception of Grammar Handbook. Budapest, Hungary: OS Hungary; 2012: 47-86
• 19 Reeves C, Schmauder AR, Morris RK. Stress grouping improves performance on an immediate serial list recall task. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 2000; 26 (06) 1638-1654
• 20 Molero Martin D, Laird R, Hwang F, Salis C. Computerized short-term memory treatment for older adults with aphasia: Feedback from clinicians. In Proceedings of ASSETS '13, Bellevue, Washington; 2013
• 21 Wilson MD. The MRC psycholinguistic database: machine readable dictionary, version 2. Behav Res Methods Instrum Comput 1988; 20: 6-11
• 22 Long A, Hesketh A, Paszek G, Booth M, Bowen A. Development of a reliable self-report outcome measure for pragmatic trials of communication therapy following stroke: the Communication Outcome after Stroke (COAST) scale. Clin Rehabil 2008; 22 (12) 1083-1094
• 23 Lomas J, Pickard L, Bester S, Elbard H, Finlayson A, Zoghaib C. The communicative effectiveness index: development and psychometric evaluation of a functional communication measure for adult aphasia. J Speech Hear Disord 1989; 54 (01) 113-124
• 24 Ledford JR, Gast DL. Measuring procedural fidelity in behavioural research. Neuropsychol Rehabil 2014; 24 (3-4): 332-348
• 25 Barde LHF, Schwartz MF, Chrysikou EG, Thompson-Schill SL. Reduced short-term memory span in aphasia and susceptibility to interference: contribution of material-specific maintenance deficits. Neuropsychologia 2010; 48 (04) 909-920
• 26 Gvion A, Friedmann N. Does phonological working memory impairment affect sentence comprehension? A study of conduction aphasia. Aphasiology 2012; 26: 494-535
• 27 Caplan D, Michaud J, Hufford R. Mechanisms underlying syntactic comprehension deficits in vascular aphasia: new evidence from self-paced listening. Cogn Neuropsychol 2015; 32 (05) 283-313
• 28 Salthouse TA, Meinz EJ. Aging, inhibition, working memory, and speed. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci 1995; 50 (06) 297-306
• 29 Marshall J. The mapping hypothesis and aphasia therapy. Aphasiology 1995; 9: 517-539
• 30 Murray L, Salis C, Martin N, Dralle J. The use of standardised short-term and working memory tests in aphasia research: a systematic review. Neuropsychol Rehabil 2016; 1-43
• 31 Tate RL, Perdices M, Rosenkoetter U. , et al. The single-case reporting guideline In BEhavioural interventions (SCRIBE) 2016 statement. Neuropsychol Rehabil 2017; 27 (01) 1-15
• 32 Howard D, Franklin S. Memory without rehearsal. In: Vallar G, Shallice T. , eds. Neuropsychological Impairments of Short-Term Memory. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1990: 287-318
• 33 Goodglass H, Kaplan E, Barresi B. The Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination. 3rd ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2001
• 34 Dabul B. Apraxia Battery for Adults. 2nd ed. Austin, TX: Pro-Ed; 2000
• 35 Swinburn K, Porter G, Howard D. Comprehensive Aphasia Test. Hove, UK: Psychology Press; 2004
• 36 Wechsler D. Wechsler Memory Scale—Revised. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation; 1987