Facial Nerve Outcome after Vestibular Schwannoma Resection: A Comparative Meta-Analysis of Endoscopic versus Open Retrosigmoid Approach

Abstract

The minimal access retrosigmoid endoscopic approach to vestibular schwannoma (VS) resection has been used with promising results. However, it has not been compared with the standard open approach in the literature. We performed a meta-analysis review for all articles describing both approaches for VS from 1996 to 2011. We found 1861 articles. After review and discussion, we narrowed our study to 25 articles, 4 endoscopic and 21 open. The total number of patients was 3026 for open and 790 for endoscopic. The mean tumor sizes in the open and endoscopic series were 2.5 cm and 2.7 cm, respectively. Good facial nerve outcome was achieved in 67% of the open series patients and in 94% of the endoscopic series patients. Other outcomes in the open and endoscopic series were the following: gross total resection, 91% versus 97%; functional hearing, 22.6% versus 46%; wound infection, 1.3% versus 2.6%; and recurrence, 5.4% versus 2.2%. We acknowledge the limitations of our study, but we can state that the endoscopic approach is not inferior to the standard open approach. In expert hands the endoscopic approach can offer as good a result as the open, with potential benefits such as less pain and a shorter length of stay in the hospital. There is a need for more controlled studies for a definitive comparison.

Keywords

vestibular schwannoma - endoscopic surgery - retrosigmoid approach - facial nerve

• References

• 1 House JW, Brackmann DE. Facial nerve grading system. Head Neck Surg 1985; 93: 146-147
• 2 Jarrahy R, Eby JB, Cha ST, Shahinian HK. Fully endoscopic vascular decompression of the trigeminal nerve. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 2002; 45 (1) 32-35
• 3 Valtonen HJ, Poe DS, Heilman CB, Tarlov EC. Endoscopically assisted prevention of cerebrospinal fluid leak in suboccipital acoustic neuroma surgery. Am J Otol 1997; 18 (3) 381-385
• 4 Shahinian HK, Eby JB, Ocon M. Fully endoscopic excision of vestibular schwannomas. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 2004; 47 (6) 329-332
• 5 Shahinian HK, Ra Y. 527 fully endoscopic resections of vestibular schwannomas. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 2011; 54 (2) 61-67
• 6 Pieper DR. The endoscopic approach to vestibular schwannomas and posterolateral skull base pathology. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 2012; 45 (2) 439-454 , x x.
• 7 Matthies C, Samii M. Management of 1000 vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas): clinical presentation. Neurosurgery 1997; 40 (1) 1-9 ; discussion 9–10
• 8 Samii M, Matthies C. Management of 1000 vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas): the facial nerve—preservation and restitution of function. Neurosurgery 1997; 40 (4) 684-694 ; discussion 694–695
• 9 Samii M, Matthies C. Management of 1000 vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas): hearing function in 1000 tumor resections. Neurosurgery 1997; 40 (2) 248-260 ; discussion 260–262
• 10 Samii M, Matthies C. Management of 1000 vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas): surgical management and results with an emphasis on complications and how to avoid them. Neurosurgery 1997; 40 (1) 11-21 , discussion 21–23
• 11 Yang J, Grayeli AB, Barylyak R, Elgarem H. Functional outcome of retrosigmoid approach in vestibular schwannoma surgery. Acta Otolaryngol 2008; 128 (8) 881-886
• 12 Colletti V, Fiorino FG. Retrosigmoid-transmeatal en bloc removal of small to medium-sized acoustic neuromas. Otolaryngology–head and neck surgery: official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-. Head Neck Surg 1999; 120: 122-128
• 13 Moffat DA, da Cruz MJ, Baguley DM, Beynon GJ, Hardy DG. Hearing preservation in solitary vestibular schwannoma surgery using the retrosigmoid approach. Head Neck Surg 1999; 121: 781-788
• 14 Jung S, Kang SS, Kim TS , et al. Current surgical results of retrosigmoid approach in extralarge vestibular schwannomas. Surg Neurol 2000; 53 (4) 370-377 ; discussion 377–378
• 15 Mazzoni A, Calabrese V, Danesi G. A modified retrosigmoid approach for direct exposure of the fundus of the internal auditory canal for hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery. Am J Otol 2000; 21 (1) 98-109
• 16 Tonn JC, Schlake HP, Goldbrunner R, Milewski C, Helms J, Roosen K. Acoustic neuroma surgery as an interdisciplinary approach: a neurosurgical series of 508 patients. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2000; 69 (2) 161-166
• 17 Strauss C. The facial nerve in medial acoustic neuromas. J Neurosurg 2002; 97 (5) 1083-1090
• 18 Lassaletta L, Fontes L, Melcon E, Sarria MJ, Gavilan J. Hearing preservation with the retrosigmoid approach for vestibular schwannoma: myth or reality? . Head Neck Surg 2003; 129: 397-401
• 19 Maw AR, Coakham HB, Ayoub O, Butler SR. Hearing preservation and facial nerve function in vestibular schwannoma surgery. Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci 2003; 28 (3) 252-256
• 20 Yamakami I, Uchino Y, Kobayashi E, Yamaura A, Oka N. Removal of large acoustic neurinomas (vestibular schwannomas) by the retrosigmoid approach with no mortality and minimal morbidity. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2004; 75 (3) 453-458
• 21 Darwish BS, Bird PA, Goodisson DW, Bonkowski JA, MacFarlane MR. Facial nerve function and hearing preservation after retrosigmoid excision of vestibular schwannoma: Christchurch Hospital experience with 97 patients. ANZ J Surg 2005; 75 (10) 893-896
• 22 Zhang X, Fei Z, Chen YJ , et al. Facial nerve function after excision of large acoustic neuromas via the suboccipital retrosigmoid approach. J Clin Neurosci 2005; 12 (4) 405-408
• 23 Samii M, Gerganov V, Samii A. Improved preservation of hearing and facial nerve function in vestibular schwannoma surgery via the retrosigmoid approach in a series of 200 patients. J Neurosurg 2006; 105 (4) 527-535
• 24 Sinha S, Sharma BS. Cystic acoustic neuromas: surgical outcome in a series of 58 patients. J Clin Neurosci 2008; 15 (5) 511-515
• 25 Veronezi RJ, Fernandes YB, Borges G, Ramina R. Long-term facial nerve clinical evaluation following vestibular schwannoma surgery. Arq Neuropsiquiatr 2008; 66 0A 194-198
• 26 Chen L, Chen L, Liu L , et al. Vestibular schwannoma microsurgery with special reference to facial nerve preservation. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 2009; 111 (1) 47-53
• 27 Chen L, Chen LH, Ling F, Liu YS, Samii M, Samii A. Removal of vestibular schwannoma and facial nerve preservation using small suboccipital retrosigmoid craniotomy. Chin Med J (Engl) 2010; 123 (3) 274-280
• 28 Zhao X, Wang Z, Ji Y , et al. Long-term facial nerve function evaluation following surgery for large acoustic neuromas via retrosigmoid transmeatal approach. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2010; 152 (10) 1647-1652
• 29 Di Maio S, Malebranche AD, Westerberg B, Akagami R. Hearing preservation after microsurgical resection of large vestibular schwannomas. Neurosurgery 2011; 68 (3) 632-640 ; discussion 640
• 30 Gerganov VM, Pirayesh A, Nouri M , et al. Hydrocephalus associated with vestibular schwannomas: management options and factors predicting the outcome. J Neurosurg 2011; 114 (5) 1209-1215
• 31 Göksu N, Bayazit Y, Kemaloğlu Y. Endoscopy of the posterior fossa and dissection of acoustic neuroma. J Neurosurg 1999; 91 (5) 776-780
• 32 Magnan J, Barbieri M, Mora R , et al. Retrosigmoid approach for small and medium-sized acoustic neuromas. Otol Neurotol 2002; 23 (2) 141-145
• 33 Kabil MS, Shahinian HK. A series of 112 fully endoscopic resections of vestibular schwannomas. Minim Invasive Neurosurg 2006; 49 (6) 362-368