Aerobic Versus Resistance Exercise for Overweight: Is there a Difference in Reporting Quality?

Abstract

In the management of overweight, the implementation of exercise helps to create a caloric deficit and to lose weight. Several studies have shown poor reporting quality of exercise interventions for other diseases. Thus, the purpose of this study was to assess the completeness of exercise intervention reporting in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) for the treatment of overweight and to evaluate potential differences between exercise modalities. Two independent reviewers applied two intervention reporting guidelines to 47 RCTs on the management of overweight. The completeness of intervention reporting was evaluated using descriptive statistics. Potential differences in reporting quality between studies using aerobic exercise (AE) vs. studies using combined aerobic and resistance exercise (ARE) were calculated with a χ² test. Overall, studies completed 61% and 47%, respectively, of the guideline items. The χ² analysis of exercise modalities showed a significant difference for two items regarding exercise progression (91% AE vs. 38% ARE, p<0.001) and detailed description of exercises (0% AE vs. 50% ARE, p<0.001). Reporting of exercise interventions in the treatment of overweight was found insufficient. The detected differences between exercise modalities imply the need for improved guidelines.

Keywords

TIDieR - CERT - exercise interventions - reporting quality - overweight

Publikationsverlauf

Eingereicht: 28. November 2024

Angenommen: 19. April 2025

Artikel online veröffentlicht:
28. Juli 2025

• References

• 1 World Health Organization. Prevalence of overweight among adults, BMI >=25 (crude estimate) (%) (2025). Available online: https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/indicators/indicator-details/GHO/prevalence-of-overweight-among-adults-bmi-greaterequal-25-(crude-estimate)-(-) Accessed: 14 Mar 2025
• 2 World Health Organization. Prevalence of overweight among adults, BMI >=30 (crude estimate) (%) (2025). Available online: https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/indicators/indicator-details/GHO/prevalence-of-obesity-among-adults-bmi-=-30-(crude-estimate)-(-) Accessed: 14 Mar 2025
• 3 World Health Organization. Guideline: Assessing and managing children at primary health-care facilities to prevent overweight and obesity in the context of the double burden of malnutrition. Updates for the integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI). Geneva: World Health Organization; 2017
• 4 Després JP, Lemieux I, Prud'homme D. Treatment of obesity: Need to focus on high risk abdominally obese patients. BMJ 2001; 322: 716-720
• 5 Guh DP, Zhang W, Bansback N. et al. The incidence of co-morbidities related to obesity and overweight: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Public Health 2009; 9: 88
• 6 Berrington de Gonzalez A, Hartge P, Cerhan JR. et al. Body-mass index and mortality among 1.46 million white adults. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 2211-2219
• 7 Hauner H, Moss A, Berg A. et al. Interdisziplinäre Leitlinie der Qualität S3 zur “Prävention und Therapie der Adipositas” 2.0. 2014
• 8 Jensen MD, Ryan DH, Apovian CM. et al. 2013 AHA/ACC/TOS guideline for the management of overweight and obesity in adults: A report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines and The Obesity Society. Circulation 2014; 129: S102-S138
• 9 Garvey WT, Mechanick JI, Brett EM. et al. American Association Of Clinical Endocrinologists And American College Of Endocrinology Comprehensive Clinical Practice Guidelines For Medical Care Of Patients With Obesity. Endocr Pract 2016; 22: 1-203
• 10 Donnelly JE, Blair SN, Jakicic JM. et al. American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand. Appropriate physical activity intervention strategies for weight loss and prevention of weight regain for adults. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2009; 41: 459-471
• 11 Galani C, Schneider H. Prevention and treatment of obesity with lifestyle interventions: Review and meta-analysis. Int J Public Health 2007; 52: 348-359
• 12 Kelley GA, Kelley KS, Vu Tran Z. Aerobic exercise, lipids and lipoproteins in overweight and obese adults: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Int J Obes (Lond) 2005; 29: 881-893
• 13 Schaar B, Moos-Thiele C, Platen P. Effects of exercise, diet, and a combination of exercise and diet in overweight and obese adults. A meta-analysis of the data. TOSMJ 2010; 4: 17-28
• 14 Wu T, Gao X, Chen M. et al. Long-term effectiveness of diet-plus-exercise interventions vs. diet-only interventions for weight loss: A meta-analysis. Obes Rev 2009; 10: 313-323
• 15 Wallace SS, Barak G, Truong G. et al. Hierarchy of evidence within the medical literature. Hosp Pediatr 2022; 12: 745-750
• 16 Bartholdy C, Nielsen SM, Warming S. et al. Poor replicability of recommended exercise interventions for knee osteoarthritis: A descriptive analysis of evidence informing current guidelines and recommendations. Osteoarthritis Cartilage 2019; 27: 3-22
• 17 Charette M, Bérubé M-È, Brooks K. et al. How well do published randomized controlled trials on pelvic floor muscle training interventions for urinary incontinence describe the details of the intervention? A review. Neurourol Urodyn 2020; 39: 35-44
• 18 Hacke C, Nunan D, Weisser B. Do exercise trials for hypertension adequately report interventions? A reporting quality study. Int J Sports Med 2018; 39: 902-908
• 19 Mack DE, Wilson PM, Santos E. et al. Standards of reporting: The use of CONSORT PRO and CERT in individuals living with osteoporosis. Osteoporos Int 2018; 29: 305-313
• 20 Major DH, Røe Y, Grotle M. et al. Content reporting of exercise interventions in rotator cuff disease trials: Results from application of the Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT). BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med 2019; 5: e000656
• 21 Hay-Smith EJ, Englas K, Dumoulin C. et al. The Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT) in a systematic review of exercise-based rehabilitation effectiveness: Completeness of reporting, rater agreement, and utility. Eur J Phys Rehabil Med 2019; 55: 342-352
• 22 Meneses-Echavez JF, Rodriguez-Prieto I, Elkins M. et al. Analysis of reporting completeness in exercise cancer trials: A systematic review. BMC Med Res Methodol 2019; 19: 220
• 23 Keene DJ, Forde C, Sugavanam T. et al. Exercise for people with a fragility fracture of the pelvis or lower limb: A systematic review of interventions evaluated in clinical trials and reporting quality. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2020; 21: 435
• 24 Hacke C, Schreiber J, Weisser B. Application of the templates TIDieR and CERT reveal incomplete reporting and poor replicability of exercise interventions for type 2 diabetes mellitus. Curr Diabetes Rev 2022; 18: e250821195838
• 25 Bünzen C, Knuth J, Bucher M. et al. CORE-CERT items as a minimal requirement for replicability of exercise interventions: Results from application to exercise studies for breast cancer patients. J Strength Cond Res 2023; 37: e346-e360
• 26 Slade SC, Finnegan S, Dionne CE. et al. The Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT) applied to exercise interventions in musculoskeletal trials demonstrated good rater agreement and incomplete reporting. J Clin Epidemiol 2018; 103: 120-130
• 27 Thabane L, Chu R, Cuddy K. et al. What is the quality of reporting in weight loss intervention studies? A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Int J Obes (Lond) 2007; 31: 1554-1559
• 28 Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D. CONSORT 2010 statement: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. BMJ 2010; 340: c332
• 29 Hoffmann TC, Glasziou PP, Boutron I. et al. Better reporting of interventions: Template for intervention description and replication (TIDieR) checklist and guide. BMJ 2014; 348: g1687
• 30 Slade SC, Dionne CE, Underwood M. et al. Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT): explanation and elaboration statement. Br J Sports Med 2016; 50: 1428-1437
• 31 WHO Consultation on Obesity, World Health Organization. Obesity: preventing and managing the global epidemic : report of a WHO consultation. Available online https://iris.who.int/handle/10665/42330
• 32 Yumuk V, Tsigos C, Fried M. et al. European Guidelines for Obesity Management in Adults. Obes Facts 2015; 8: 402-424
• 33 Chan A-W, Tetzlaff JM, Gøtzsche PC. et al. SPIRIT 2013 explanation and elaboration: Guidance for protocols of clinical trials. BMJ 2013; 346: e7586
• 34 Ammann BC, Knols RH, Baschung P. et al. Application of principles of exercise training in sub-acute and chronic stroke survivors: A systematic review. BMC Neurol 2014; 14: 167
• 35 Winters-Stone KM, Neil SE, Campbell KL. Attention to principles of exercise training: A review of exercise studies for survivors of cancers other than breast. Br J Sports Med 2014; 48: 987-995
• 36 Byrt T, Bishop J, Carlin JB. Bias, prevalence and kappa. J Clin Epidemiol 1993; 46: 423-429
• 37 Sim J, Wright CC. The kappa statistic in reliability studies: Use, interpretation, and sample size requirements. Phys Ther 2005; 85: 257-268
• 38 Chen G, Faris P, Hemmelgarn B. et al. Measuring agreement of administrative data with chart data using prevalence unadjusted and adjusted kappa. BMC Med Res Methodol 2009; 9: 5
• 39 McHugh ML. Interrater reliability: The kappa statistic. Biochem Med (Zagreb) 2012; 22: 276-282
• 40 Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 1977; 33: 159-174
• 41 Shaw K, Gennat H, O'Rourke P. et al. Exercise for overweight or obesity. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2006; 4: CD003817
• 42 Schwingshackl L, Dias S, Strasser B. et al. Impact of different training modalities on anthropometric and metabolic characteristics in overweight/obese subjects: A systematic review and network meta-analysis. PLoS One 2013; 8: e82853
• 43 Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM. et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 2021; 372: n71
• 44 Garber CE, Blissmer B, Deschenes MR. et al. American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Quantity and quality of exercise for developing and maintaining cardiorespiratory, musculoskeletal, and neuromotor fitness in apparently healthy adults: guidance for prescribing exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2011; 43: 1334-1359
• 45 Abell B, Glasziou P, Hoffmann T. Reporting and replicating trials of exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation: Do we know what the researchers actually did?. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2015; 8: 187-194
• 46 Palmer W, Okonya O, Jellison S. et al. Intervention reporting of clinical trials published in high-impact cardiology journals: Effect of the TIDieR checklist and guide. BMJ Evid Based Med 2021; 26: 91-97
• 47 Rauh SL, Turner D, Jellison S. et al. Completeness of intervention reporting of clinical trials published in highly ranked obesity journals. Obesity (Silver Spring) 2021; 29: 285-293
• 48 Tew GA, Brabyn S, Cook L. et al. The completeness of intervention descriptions in randomised trials of supervised exercise training in peripheral arterial disease. PLoS One 2016; 11: e0150869