Endurance Performance Adaptations between SSG and HIIT in Soccer Players: A Meta-analysis

Abstract

The objective of this systematic review with meta-analysis was to compare the endurance performance chronic adaptations induced by running-based high-intensity interval training (HIIT), small-sided games (SSGs), and combined HIIT+SSGs in male and female youth and adult soccer players. The studies included in this review followed the PICOS criteria: (i) healthy soccer players; (ii) interventions based on SSGs; (iii) comparators exposed to only HIIT or combined SSGs+HIIT; (iv) endurance performance variables. Studies were searched for in the following databases: (i) PubMed; (ii) Scopus; (iii) SPORTDiscus; (iv) Web of Science. After conducting an initial database search that retrieved a total of 5,389 records, a thorough screening process resulted in the inclusion of 20 articles that met the eligibility criteria. Sixteen studies reported outcomes related to endurance performance measured through field-based tests, while five studies provided results from direct measurements of maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max). Results showed a non-significant small-magnitude favoring effect for the HIIT groups compared to the SSG groups (ES=0.37, p=0.074) for endurance, while a non-significant small-magnitude favoring SSGs was observed (ES=–0.20, p=0.303) for VO2max. Despite the very low certainty of evidence, the findings suggest similar effects induced by both SSG and HIIT on improving endurance performance and VO2max.

Key words

football - high-intensity interval training - aerobic exercise - athletic performance - physical fitness

Publikationsverlauf

Eingereicht: 06. Juli 2023

Angenommen: 04. September 2023

Accepted Manuscript online:
07. September 2023

Artikel online veröffentlicht:
13. November 2023

• References

• 1 Stolen T, Chamari K, Castagna C. et al. Physiology of soccer: An update. Sports Medicine 2005; 35: 501-536
• 2 Bradley PS, Archer DT, Hogg B. et al. Tier-specific evolution of match performance characteristics in the English Premier League: It’s getting tougher at the top. J Sports Sci 2016; 34: 980-987
• 3 Hoff J, Helgerud J. Endurance and Strength Training for Soccer Players. Sports Medicine 2004; 34: 165-180
• 4 Helgerud J, Engen LC, Wisloff U. et al. Aerobic endurance training improves soccer performance./L ’ entrainement d ’ endurance ameliore les performances au football. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2001; 33: 1925-1931
• 5 Castagna C, Impellizzeri F, Cecchini EMC. et al. Effects of intermittent-endurance fitness on match performance in young male soccer players. J Strength Cond Res 2009; 23: 1954-1959
• 6 Tønnessen E, Hem E, Leirstein S. et al. Maximal aerobic power characteristics of male professional soccer players, 1989-2012. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2013; 8: 323-329
• 7 Clemente FM, Ramirez-Campillo R, Nakamura FY. et al. Effects of high-intensity interval training in men soccer player’s physical fitness: A systematic review with meta-analysis of randomized-controlled and non-controlled trials. J Sports Sci 2021; 39: 1202-1222
• 8 Laursen PB, Jenkins DG. The Scientific Basis for High-Intensity Interval Training. Sports Medicine 2002; 32: 53-73
• 9 Engel FA, Ackermann A, Chtourou H. et al. High-Intensity Interval Training Performed by Young Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front Physiol 2018; 9: 1012
• 10 Dolci F, Kilding AE, Chivers P. et al. High-intensity interval training shock microcycle for enhancing sport performance: A brief review. J Strength Cond Res 2020; 34: 1188-1196
• 11 Milanović Z, Sporiš G, Weston M. Effectiveness of high-intensity interval training (HIT) and continuous endurance training for VO2max improvements: A systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled trials. Sports Medicine 2015; 45: 1469-1481
• 12 Esfarjani F, Laursen PB. Manipulating high-intensity interval training: Effects on VO2max, the lactate threshold and 3000m running performance in moderately trained males. J Sci Med Sport 2007; 10: 27-35
• 13 Beato M, Drust B, Iacono AD. Implementing high-speed running and sprinting training in professional soccer. Int J Sports Med 2021; 42: 295-299
• 14 Buchheit M. Managing high-speed running load in professional soccer players: The benefit of high-intensity interval training supplementation. Sport Performance & Science Reports 2019; 53: 1-5
• 15 Buchheit M, Laursen PB. High-intensity interval training, solutions to the programming puzzle: Part ii: anaerobic energy, neuromuscular load and practical applications. Sports Medicine 2013; 43: 313-338
• 16 Talanian JL, Galloway SDR, Heigenhauser GJF. et al. Two weeks of high-intensity aerobic interval training increases the capacity for fat oxidation during exercise in women. J Appl Physiol 2007; 102: 1439-1447
• 17 Gibala MJ, McGee SL. Metabolic adaptations to short-term high-intensity interval training. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 2008; 36: 58-63
• 18 Edge J, Bishop D, Goodman C. The effects of training intensity on muscle buffer capacity in females. Eur J Appl Physiol 2006; 96: 97-105
• 19 Hostrup M, Bangsbo J. Limitations in intense exercise performance of athletes – effect of speed endurance training on ion handling and fatigue development. J Physiol 2017; 595: 2897-2913
• 20 Buchheit M. The 30-15 intermittent fitness test: Accuracy for individualizing interval training of young intermittent sport players. J Strength Cond Res 2008; 22: 365-374
• 21 Bok D, Gulin J, Gregov C. Accuracy of the 20-m shuttle run test for individualizing exercise intensity of high-intensity interval training. Kinesiology. Clemente FM. Afonso 2023; 55: 3-12
• 22 J, Sarmento H. Small-sided games: An umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. PLoS One 2021; 16: e0247067
• 23 Clemente FM, Ramirez-Campillo R, Sarmento H. et al. Effects of small-sided game interventions on the technical execution and tactical behaviors of young and youth team sports players: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Front Psychol 2021; 12: 667041
• 24 Clemente FM, Sarmento H. The effects of small-sided soccer games on technical actions and skills: A systematic review. Human Movement 2020; 21: 100-119
• 25 Clemente FM, Afonso J, Castillo D. et al. The effects of small-sided soccer games on tactical behavior and collective dynamics: A systematic review. Chaos Solitons Fractals 2020; 134: 109710
• 26 Hill-Haas SV, Dawson BT, Impellizzeri FM. et al. Physiology of small-sided games training in football: A systematic review. Sports Medicine 2011; 41: 199-220
• 27 Bujalance-Moreno P, Latorre-Román PÁ, García-Pinillos F. et al. A systematic review on small-sided games in football players: Acute and chronic adaptations. J Sports Sci 2019; 37: 921-949
• 28 Faga J, Bishop C, Maloney SJ. Does size matter? Effects of small versus large pitch small-sided game training on speed and endurance in collegiate soccer players. Int J Sports Sci Coach. Ahead-of-print.
• 29 Boraczyński MT, Laskin JJ, Gajewski J. et al. Effects of two low-volume high-intensity interval training protocols in professional soccer: Sprint interval training versus small-sided games. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2022; 63: 23-33
• 30 Radziminski L, Rompa P, Barnat W. et al. A comparison of the physiological and technical effects of high-intensity running and small-sided games in young soccer players. Int J Sports Sci Coach 2013; 8: 455-465
• 31 Guard AN, McMillan K, MacFarlane NG. The influence of relative playing area and player numerical imbalance on physical and perceptual demands in soccer small-sided game formats. Science and Medicine in Football 2022; 6: 221-227
• 32 Lacome M, Simpson BM, Cholley Y. et al. Small-Sided Games in Elite Soccer: Does One Size Fit All?. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2018; 13: 568-576
• 33 Beato M, de Keijzer KL, Costin AJ. External and internal training load comparison between sided-game drills in professional soccer. Front Sports Act Living 2023; 5: 1150461
• 34 Beato M, Vicens-Bordas J, Peña J. et al. Training load comparison between small, medium, and large-sided games in professional football. Front Sports Act Living 2023; 5: 1165242
• 35 Rebelo ANC, Silva P, Rago V. et al. Differences in strength and speed demands between 4v4 and 8v8 small-sided football games. J Sports Sci 2016; 34: 2246-2254
• 36 Arslan E, Orer G, Clemente F. Running-based high-intensity interval training vs. small-sided game training programs: Effects on the physical performance, psychophysiological responses and technical skills in young soccer players. Biol Sport 2020; 37: 165-173
• 37 Clemente FM, Soylu Y, Arslan E. et al. Can high-intensity interval training and small-sided games be effective for improving physical fitness after detraining? A parallel study design in youth male soccer players. PeerJ. 2022; 10: e13514
• 38 Nobari H, Silva AF, Vali N. et al. Comparing the physical effects of combining small-sided games with short high-intensity interval training or repeated sprint training in youth soccer players: A parallel-study design. Int J Sports Sci Coach 2022; 18: 1142-1154
• 39 Harrison CB, Kinugasa T, Gill N. et al. Aerobic fitness for young athletes: Combining game-based and high-intensity interval training. Int J Sports Med 2015; 36: 929-934
• 40 Moran J, Blagrove RC, Drury B. et al. Effects of small-sided games vs. conventional endurance training on endurance performance in male youth soccer players: A meta-analytical comparison. Sports Medicine 2019; 49: 731-742
• 41 Clemente FM, Ramirez-Campillo R, Afonso J. et al. Effects of small-sided games vs. running-based high-intensity interval training on physical performance in soccer players: A meta-analytical comparison. Front Physiol 2021; 12: 642703
• 42 McKay AKA, Stellingwerff T, Smith ES. et al. Defining training and performance caliber: A participant classification framework. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2022; 17: 317-331
• 43 Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM. et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021; 71
• 44 Higgins J, Thomas J. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. USA: Cochrane. 2021
• 45 Rechenchosky L, Menegassi VM, Jaime M. et al. Scoping review of tests to assess tactical knowledge and tactical performance of young soccer players. J Sports Sci 2021; 39: 2051-2067
• 46 Macpherson TW, Weston M. The effect of low-volume sprint interval training on the development and subsequent maintenance of aerobic fitness in soccer players. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2015; 10: 332-338
• 47 Drevon D, Fursa SR, Malcolm AL. Intercoder reliability and validity of webplotdigitizer in extracting graphed data. Behav Modif 2017; 41: 323-339
• 48 Sterne JAC, Savović J, Page MJ. et al. RoB 2: A revised tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ. 2019; 366: l4898
• 49 Sterne JA, Hernán MA, Reeves BC. et al. ROBINS-I: a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions. BMJ. 2016; 355: i4919
• 50 Jackson D, Turner R. Power analysis for random-effects meta-analysis. Res Synth Methods 2017; 8: 290-302
• 51 Green S, Higgins J, Green S. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. NJ, USA. John Wiley & Sons; Hoboken: 2005
• 52 Deeks JJ, Higgins JP, Altman DG. Analysing data and undertaking meta-analyses. In: Higgins JP, Green S, eds. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. The Cochrane Collaboration. 2008: 243-296
• 53 Kontopantelis E, Springate DA, Reeves DA. Re-Analysis of the cochrane library data: the dangers of unobserved heterogeneity in meta-analyses. Friede T, editor. PLoS One 2013; 8: e69930
• 54 Hopkins WG, Marshall SW, Batterham AM. et al. Progressive statistics for studies in sports medicine and exercise science. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2009; 41: 3-13
• 55 Kadlec D, Sainani KL, Nimphius S. With great power comes great responsibility: common errors in meta-analyses and meta-regressions in strength & conditioning research. Sports Medicine 2023; 53: 313-325
• 56 Higgins, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. Special topics in statistics. In: Higgins, JP, Green S, ed. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions: The Cochrane. 2008: 481-529
• 57 Higgins JPT, Thompson SG. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 2002; 21: 1539-1558
• 58 Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M. et al. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ Clinical Research 1997; 315: 629-634
• 59 Duval S, Tweedie RTrim and Fill A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics. 2000; 56: 455-463
• 60 Shi L, Lin L, Omboni S. The trim-and-fill method for publication bias: Practical guidelines and recommendations based on a large database of meta-analyses. Medicine. 2019; 98: e15987
• 61 Johansen JM, Goleva-Fjellet S, Sunde A. et al. No change – no gain; the effect of age, sex, selected genes and training on physiological and performance adaptations in cross-country skiing. Front Physiol 2020; 11: 581339
• 62 Owen AL, Wong DP, Paul D. et al Physical and technical comparisons between various-sided games within professional soccer. Int J Sports Med 2014; 35: 286-292
• 63 Moran J, Sandercock G, Ramirez-Campillo R. et al. A meta-analysis of resistance training in female youth: its effect on muscular strength, and shortcomings in the literature. Sports Med 2018; 48: 1661-1671
• 64 Moran J, Sandercock GRH, Ramírez-Campillo R. et al. A meta-analysis of maturation-related variation in adolescent boy athletes’ adaptations to short-term resistance training. J Sports Sci 2017; 35: 1041-1051
• 65 Moran J, Clark CCT, Ramirez-Campillo R. et al. A meta-analysis of plyometric training in female youth: its efficacy and shortcomings in the literature. J Strength Cond Res 2019; 33: 1996-2008
• 66 Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA. et al. GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction – GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. J Clin Epidemiol 2011; 64: 383-394
• 67 Zhang Y, Alonso-Coello P, Guyatt GH. et al. GRADE Guidelines: 19. Assessing the certainty of evidence in the importance of outcomes or values and preferences – Risk of bias and indirectness. J Clin Epidemiol 2019; 111: 94-104
• 68 Zhang Y, Coello PA, Guyatt GH. et al. GRADE guidelines: 20. Assessing the certainty of evidence in the importance of outcomes or values and preferences – inconsistency, imprecision, and other domains. J Clin Epidemiol 2019; 111: 83-93
• 69 Arianto AT, Setyawan C. Efektivitas small sided games dan interval training terhadap peningkatan daya tahan aerobik pada pemain sepakbola U-17 [Effect of small sided games and interval training on aerobic endurance of U-17 soccer players]. Jurnal Keolahragaan 2019; 7: 182-191
• 70 Faude O, Steffen A, Kellmann M. et al. The effect of short-term interval training during the competitive season on physical fitness and signs of fatigue: a crossover trial in high-level youth football players. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2014; 9: 936-944
• 71 Impellizzeri FM, Marcora SM, Castagna C. et al. Physiological and performance effects of generic versus specific aerobic training in soccer players. Int J Sports Med 2006; 27: 483-492
• 72 Nayıroğlu S, Yılmaz AK, Silva AF. et al. Effects of small-sided games and running-based high-intensity interval training on body composition and physical fitness in under-19 female soccer players. BMC Sports Sci Med Rehabil 2022; 14: 119
• 73 Koral J, Lloria Varella J. Lazaro et al. Effects of three preseason training programs on speed, change-of-direction, and endurance in recreationally trained soccer players. Front Physiol 2021; 12: 1525
• 74 Castillo D, Raya-González J, Sarmento H. et al. Effects of including endurance and speed sessions within small-sided soccer games periodization on physical fitness. Biol Sport 2021; 38: 291-299
• 75 Safania AM, Alizadeh R, Nourshahi MA. Comparison of small-side games and interval training on same selected physical fitness factors in amateur soccer players. J Social Sci 2011; 7: 349-353
• 76 Mohr M, Krustrup P. Comparison between two types of anaerobic speed endurance training in competitive soccer players. J Hum Kinet 2016; 51: 183-192
• 77 Akdoğan E, Yılmaz İ, Köklü Y. et al. The effect of isolated or combined small-sided games and speed endurance training on physical performance parameters in young soccer players. Kinesiology 2021; 53: 78-85
• 78 Seipp D, Quittmann OJ, Fasold F. et al. Concurrent training in team sports: A systematic review. Int J Sports Sci Coach 2023; 18: 1342-1364
• 79 Brink MS, Visscher C, Arends S. et al. Monitoring stress and recovery: New insights for the prevention of injuries and illnesses in elite youth soccer players. Br J Sports Med 2010; 44: 809-815
• 80 Gonçalves L, Camões M, Lima R. et al Characterization of external load in different types of exercise in professional soccer. Hum Movement. 2021; 23: 89-95 81. Walton CC, Gwyther K, Gao CX, et al. Evidence of gender imbalance across samples in sport and exercise psychology. Int Rev Sport Exerc Psychol. 2022 ahead-of-print
• 81 Walton CC, Gwyther K, Gao CX. et al Evidence of gender imbalance across samples in sport and exercise psychology. Int Rev Sport Exerc Psychol. 2022 ahead-of-print
• 82 Harrison GE, Vickers E, Fletcher D. et al. Elite female soccer players’ dual career plans and the demands they encounter. J Appl Sport Psychol 2022; 34: 133-154
• 83 Boraczyński MT, Laskin JJ, Gajewski J. et al. Effects of two low-volume high-intensity interval training protocols in professional soccer: Sprint interval training versus small-sided games. J Sports Med Physical Fitness 2023; 63: 23-33
• 84 Castillo D, Raya-González J, Sarmento H. et al. Effects of including endurance and speed session within small-sided soccer games periodization on physical fitness. Biol Sport 2021; 38: 291-299
• 85 Jastrzebski Z, Barnat W, Dargiewicz R. et al. Effect of in-season generic and soccer-specific high-intensity interval training in young soccer players. Int J Sports Sci Coach 2014; 9: 1169-1179
• 86 Ouertatani Z, Selmi O, Marsigliante S. et al. Comparison of the physical, physiological, and psychological responses of the high-intensity interval (HIIT) and small-sided games (SSG) training programs in young elite soccer players. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2022; 19: 13807
• 87 Dellal A, Varliette C, Owen A. et al. Small-Sided games versus interval training in amateur soccer players. J Strength Cond Res 2012; 26: 2712-2720
• 88 Hill-Haas SV, Coutts AJ, Rowsell GJ. et al. Generic versus small-sided game training in soccer. Int J Sports Med 2009; 30: 636-642
• 89 Arcos AL, Vázquez JS, Martín J. et al. Effects of small-sided games vs . interval training in aerobic fitness and physical enjoyment in young elite soccer players. PLoS One 2015; 10: e0137224
• 90 Eniseler N, Şahan Ç, Özcan I. et al. High-intensity small-sided games versus repeated sprint training in junior soccer players. J Hum Kinet 2017; 60: 101-111
• 91 Coyle EF. Integration of the physiological factors determining endurance performance ability. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 1995; 23: 25-63
• 92 Bangsbo J, Iaia FM, Krustrup P. The Yo-Yo Intermittent Recovery Test. Sports Med 2008; 38: 37-51
• 93 Kaufmann S, Hoos O, Kuehl T. et al. Energetic profiles of the yo-yo intermittent recovery tests 1 and 2. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2020; 15: 1400-1405
• 94 Buchheit M. The 30-15 Intermittent Fitness. Test: 10 year review 2010; 1: 1-9
• 95 Haydar B, Haddad HAl, Ahmaidi S. et al. Assessing inter-effort recovery and change of direction ability with the 30-15 Intermittent Fitness Test. J Sports Sci Med 2011; 10: 346-354
• 96 Clemente FM, Aquino R, Praça GM. et al. Variability of internal and external loads and technical/tactical outcomes during small-sided soccer games: A systematic review. Biol Sport 2022; 3: 647-672
• 97 Dello Iacono A, Beato M, Unnithan V. Comparative effects of game profile-based training and small-sided games on physical performance of elite young soccer players. J Strength Cond Res 2021; 35: 2810-2817
• 98 Clemente FM. The threats of small-sided soccer games. Strength Cond J 2020; 42: 100-105
• 99 Clemente FM, Sarmento H. Combining small-sided soccer games and running-based methods: A systematic review. Biol Sport 2021; 38: 617-627
• 100 Buchheit M, Laursen PB. High-intensity interval training, solutions to the programming puzzle: Part I: cardiopulmonary emphasis. Sports Med 2013; 43: 313-338
• 101 Castagna C, D’Ottavio S, Cappelli S. et al. The effects of long sprint ability-oriented small-sided games using different ratios of players to pitch area on internal and external load in soccer players. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2019; 14: 1265-1272
• 102 Green HJ, Jones LL, Painter DC. Effects of short-term training on cardiac function during prolonged exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1990; 22: 488-493
• 103 Dohlmann TL, Hindsø M, Dela F. et al. High-intensity interval training changes mitochondrial respiratory capacity differently in adipose tissue and skeletal muscle. Physiol Rep 2018; 6: e13857
• 104 Christensen PM, Jacobs RA, Bonne T. et al. A short period of high-intensity interval training improves skeletal muscle mitochondrial function and pulmonary oxygen uptake kinetics. J Appl Physiol 2016; 120: 1319-1327
• 105 Dellal A, Varliette C, Owen A. et al. Small-sided games versus interval training in amateur soccer players: Effects on the aerobic capacity and the ability to perform intermittent exercises with changes of direction. J Strength Cond Res 2012; 26: 2712-2720
• 106 Herazo Sánchez RT, Jimenez Trujillo JO, Gaviria et al. Efectos de los Juegos en Espacio Reducido (JER) sobre VO2máx. en futbolistas [Small sided games effects on maximum oxygen uptake in amateur soccer players]. Educación Física y Deporte 2020; 38: 137-162